How about he guesses one person a night, and gets to see what that person says during the night? That would remove the anonymity, of course, but would it make the role less OP?

I'm with franco on this one, its too OP.

OP, should have stricter win condition- ie: guesses one person nightly. If that person is mafia twice in a row, he wins, unless there's only one mafia, then he Fool Loses (5 points for surviving but not winning)

what if he can see meetings but not votes?

This is really too good for town. But nice idea.

What do you guys think?