Lawl! Deaf man = Does not hear town meeting, but if the doctor or nurse visits him, he's fixed. And if a killing role visits him, they'll feel bad and go back home. (With the exception of serial killer, werewolf, and other people that wouldn't feel bad for deaf people.)
So basically someone who is perma fiddled? I'd say give him something positive to offset that... also I agree with Mureaux that it should be named deaf man.