A merry Caroller sings. Santa gives gifts but mustn't give any to the naughty children. Sniper snipes but avoid your mafia friends. Voodoo must be smart with their words. Hooker sleeps around.
the problem is that with complex setups like this you can depend on mafia playing suboptimally. it has been the balancing factor to many scumsided setups
so, if this setup was balanced, that alone would make it townsided. since it should be townsided, if mafia cant get a grip this will slide further townsided
So what do I do? I can give optimal strats - many people are either not reading them or not following them. The amount of d1 sniper shots causing town auto is a joke.
ok, so initial thoughts as I look at it are that 10 players is hard to fill; but 62 plays at 54% is good. Here is the problem that I have. I think we should allow games within the 59-41% range to be played because it stimulates a challenge to be more sided. People like that and it is valid. By making ALL mafia narrow into 55%-45% or less everything is just a scum hunt and that isn't fun or what EPIC [many roles and setups] Mafia [the psychological part of lying or not] should be about. If we just called this Mafia then fine.
Hi Crow, I think this is decently balanced - there are comped setups less balanced than this. The problem is apparently Voodoo and Santa are blacklisted roles. :(
deletedalmost 9 years
this is decently balanced? dude..... santa's reports are always accurate.. there is a bp and an orc which means 5 god damn prs which is ridiculous... sniper doesn't who his partners and once voodoo and hooker die it's pretty much autoloss for him.. this is luck based and town sided plz don't say this is balanced because it is not, this should only be played for fun..
CharlesMark
