it leans town because towns are dumb and want the oracle to claim day1. Have the cop claim D1, if he dies in the night, the doc was janned. Ive had games where in d1 we pegged a mafia, and discovered our doc was janned by d2. But for some reason people love orc claiming and then outing PR's with RL's.
Every time I play this setup and the cop claims d1, and the town isnt stupid about it, town wins. Every time orc claims, town loses. So why do people who arent the mafia, try to get the orc to claim? It boggles the mind.
@what poring said once i was jan, and this troll was lawyer, and didnt lawyer me. i janned doc, but cop got guilty, and lawyer was bad at cc'ing. so it is not autoloss. just close to one
deletedalmost 14 years
Atheist proposed that this setup might be better with a daystart. I don't know if he's right but it's worth consideration. It gives the town slightly (but not obnoxiously) better odds and that would even the playing field.
deletedalmost 14 years
This setup is fine as it is, town just needs to learn to scumhunt
deletedalmost 14 years
I don't think this need rebalancing, town wins plenty enough as it is