Don't autoclaim as Cop if you have a guilty on Day 1. I think a flat out scumhunt is the best option, whether or not you sheep the crier is up to you... Crier, do not cry randomly. Wait for crier lines... if you cry randomly, your message can happen at the same time other people talk, thus narrowing down who the crier could be for the mafia (increasing their odds of killing you). Overall, you can think of this as a sort of extended version of Cry N' Oh with a Cop thrown in.