Back to Forum Games

Resistance 3.0: Medieval edition!

almost 9 years

Post if you wanna join, this is a game for 8. I've run this twice before and both times were quite successful.

From the Wiki:

The Resistance is a game where players attempt to deduce one another's identities. The setting of the game is an imagined battle between a resistance group trying to overthrow the malignant government and the government spies infiltrating the resistance group. It is similar in structure to party games such as Mafia and Werewolf, where a small, secret group of informed players attempt to disrupt a larger uninformed group, while the larger group attempts to identify the spies and eliminate them. The Resistance uses slightly different mechanics from similar games, and was designed to avoid player elimination and increase available information for player decisions.

Better than mafia as no one is lynched and everyone participate till game end.

This game will be for 8 players, 5 Knights of Arthur, and 3 Minions of Mordred.

For those unfamiliar,

Each day, a player is a quest leader (this follows a set order) and nominates a certain amount of people to go on the mission.

Everyone then votes on whether the quest should push through or be aborted.

If the quest is aborted, the day ends and the next person becomes leader.

If the quest pushes through, those on the mission proceed to PM me their action for the quest. Knights of Merlin members are required to always pass the quest, whilst Minions of Mordred can choose to either pass or fail. It only takes 1 fail for a quest to fail (except on the 4th quest, which takes 2)

Win Cons:

  • If 3 of the 5 quests succeed, the Knights of Arthur win the game.

  • If 5 nominations fail in a row, the Minions of Mordred win the game.

  • If 3 of the 5 quests fail, the Minions of Mordred win the game.

Next post for roles.

almost 9 years
Would it be mean of I blocked jobey on forum's so I don't have to read anything Ian has to say since I already have them marked as scum?
almost 9 years
i left out a lot of stuff but i think that's the gist of it
almost 9 years
uranus retracting a good read and saying hey it was a reaction test is confusing. it's something i do a lot when i'm mafia and i want an easy out to get a town to vote with me. at this point i think i'm leaning uranus to be the mafia in her/sonia but it's sort of difficult since sonia fell out of existence and i really didn't like sonia's early posts. plus my reads on uranus are historically not very good

uranus continues to evaluate the game as all members of quest 2 being town which is a mafia mindset

jack is hard pushing that sonia and uranus are both town which i know is the world mafia wants town to believe in. he isn't really doing it in a scummy way though. i don't know, he's still probably town

sonrio is probably town by demeanor

i'm getting bored so i'm gonna skip ahead to whenever the next team thing ahppens

nothing to say about the next team thing it failed there was probably only 1 mafia on it

enough people have townread sonrio for sort of little reason that mafia has probably done it to blend in which makes me more confident that he is town

i believed uranus when she claimed mafia

uranus: "Anyway if even Stragger is aborting I have no qualms. Abort

Stragger mind explaining your vote? Have you changed your mind?"

reads as mafia-to-town

i think that the most likely team of 3 is uranus, cat and someone i'm townreading. by association it probably isn't sonia
almost 9 years
i like sonrio questioning stragger about the uranus + sonia pair. i'm having trouble seeing where retti's coming from but i think he believes what he's saying. i think that mafia would be perfectly ok confirming that there's 1 between uranus and sonia in exchange for two fails

lots of not alignment indicative posts from the same 4 people

"yo, host. can i sub out of this? this is insanely annoying and I'm not enjoying myself. I hate to be a baby about this but this is just not fun when I have Uranus literally not even thinking about anything. People like you, Uranus, ruin this otherwise fun game because you are completely blinded by your tunnel vision."

post of the day pinche is probably town

second mission is a pass with a confirmed mafia on it which means retti is a better person than me. i think that they sort of shot themselves in the foot which is cool. there's a possibility that there were two on it and neither wanted to risk 2 fails showing, which would probably be 1 in jack/stragger and 1 in uranus/sonia. if that were the case i would lean stragger/sonia since jack probably wouldn't do that to himself and i still think sonia is more mafia than uranus. probably an unlikely world though since i still townread stragger and jack independently, and uranus probably wouldn't put her teammate with her on mission 1

uranus saying "if we assume everyone on that mission was town we're already in autowin" worries me by a lot that i'm wrong on her. the reason that her+sonia got paired was because it was assumed that if there was a mafia they would pass it. plus hey guys we're in autowin is a scumtell on its own

lots of not alignment indicative posts about what's optimal and pinche still saying guys look at me i'm town lol
almost 9 years
You dont suspect uranus at all so we'll let ian speak and see if you change your mind
almost 9 years
"Uranus9d 6h
aight. randoming it up.

I nominate: Uranus, nicki, Sonia

Sonrio9d 5h
i feel betrayed"
sonrio and uranus probably aren't on a team together

stragger is probably town. from what i've seen when he's mafia he gets mad at what he thinks is bad play but in his first posts he just seemed disappointed

uranus is mafia for the : \ and >_<" faces

ok there's confirmed a mafia between sonia and uranus

"CAT31017d 29m
ok so that means at least one of them are mordred things

I say me, sonia, jack, and radio go on this next mission"

i don't really get this. sonia hadn't done anything that i think is worth being a townread from the three on the first mission. it might be an rng or mechanics thing i'm missing. either way cat + sonia probably isn't a team

i agree with stragger's townread on jack, and more so with jack's response to stragger's townreading jack post

sonia's doing some weird rp sh*t that's probably mafia

uranus leaning more town for less awkward posts like calling sonia a gimmicky idiot that's pretty aggressive i don't think it's like her mafia play

nickixminaj is HARD TOWN

sonia's page 4 seems sort of panicky and very much unlike her forum mafia longposts. i'm getting sort of more confident that she's the mafia in her/uranus

"Perhaps the stupid gimmick has left you a bit slow on the uptake" lol rude

i don't like sonrio's page 5 read on uranus at all but i don't know whether he believes it

i completely disagree on sending uranus + sonia on a mission together. i don't think the scum between them would pass it

pinche leaning mafia for justifying not giving reads with the "fail cause i'm not on this mission" thing

i don't like pinche's reads. i don't think nicki did anything particularly genuine and i still think sonia's mafia and if the entire reasoning for a read is that they're genuine it's a bad post by default. no idea how he got anything from the posts he quoted
almost 9 years

Sonrio says


Sonrio says

So say its me, you, stragger, uranus and pinche. youre saying theres no scum in that team then?


This was to you, sonia


Saying Jack and Cat are a scum team would be pretty hard for me to believe so...I think 4/5 are not scum? I feel like i'm misreading someone but I don't think jack and cat are on the same side and idk who I would replace on that team ahhhhhhhh (prob one of you or Pinche)
almost 9 years
the only reason i can get away with messing with sonia is because i'm actually good

welcome ian!
almost 9 years
i made it to page 29 :D
almost 9 years

Sonrio says

So say its me, you, stragger, uranus and pinche. youre saying theres no scum in that team then?


This was to you, sonia
almost 9 years

jack says

what if i'm percival


Jack i'm gonna punch you in the [Redacted] then you and caro gonna be having more then just long distance problems

That sounded way more then I meant it to be
almost 9 years
what if i'm percival
almost 9 years

jack says

(sniped that wasnt in reply to sonrio's last post)


I really hope your scum if not i'm just gonna punch you
nvm you must be scum to see who f'd up that last post you made was
almost 9 years
(sniped that wasnt in reply to sonrio's last post)
almost 9 years
26
almost 9 years
well the thing is sonrio, continuing your belief that you me and stragger are town: putting on uranus and jobey means that either you've gotten the fail from quest 1 and no other evil members OR you've got both successes from quest 1 and sonia is evil. which is why for this quest either way that's a good quest imo
almost 9 years
So say its me, you, stragger, uranus and pinche. youre saying theres no scum in that team then?
almost 9 years
I want myself on it of course but the main goal is to pass it and if you replace it with Pinche I think only 1 scum at most is on there so do what you must
almost 9 years
Thats interesting, not saying yourself?
almost 9 years

Sonrio says

would you be okay with replacing jobey with pinche and not yourself?


If that's what it takes sure
almost 9 years
would you be okay with replacing jobey with pinche and not yourself?
almost 9 years

jack says

look as merlin i am pretty confident in sonrio's team


Jack kindly go jump in a ditch
almost 9 years
Okay if were playing the Pinche card i'll just PASS w/e you put so (if) you flip town I can say I told you so when we lose with that 5
almost 9 years
look as merlin i am pretty confident in sonrio's team
almost 9 years

Sonrio says

Sonia who would you replace with who. Why do you think it'll lose, if you think jacks scum thats only 1, and i townread them all


Ian/Jobey is scum period I don't really know if I trust you 100% but i'm close if you took jack out of that I'd say okay (I think) I know for a fact you have 1 scum on that quest I don't want to risk having a 2nd