That's a perfectly reasonable way to approach the game, as long as you're willing to take a step back and re-evaluate at regular intervals. Wisdom that's been imparted on me says that trying to form partner reads before anyone has flipped is generally folly but if you wanna play that way, I won't kick and scream about it. You do you.
I like the insight we're getting to N1ed's thought process a lot, actually. The combined with the way he was frustrated my read on him wasn't stronger by now has definitely improved my opinion of the slot.
that's basically what my intent is behind outting whatever I'm thinking for the past 3 forum mafias.
deletedover 8 years
mist could you talk about any changes in your reads from ~20 pages ago to now
The AtE from Ripple rang towny to me. I don't like that I townread it but I do. There was also this post
If we have a doctor and there not on impoe tonight I will honestly slap the taste out of your mouth
that when i read it, I had the feeling it was something Ripple wouldn't think to say as scum.
Yes.
Why is UltraAug above N1ed in your reads list?
HEY IAN PLEASE GIVE ME YOUR OWN READS LIST
Because he's townier.
i'd expect you to get more out of the second half of the game. why don't you think you have
I'm taking things as they go and re-evaluating when I feel something which makes me feel I need to re-evaluate. Slots that aren't posting much content (Sonrio, Connor) aren't likely to get re-evaluated at this point...
deletedover 8 years
hey wait it's sonrio's birthday as a reward you get to move up from null to scum on my read list gratz
deletedover 8 years
That's a perfectly reasonable way to approach the game, as long as you're willing to take a step back and re-evaluate at regular intervals. Wisdom that's been imparted on me says that trying to form partner reads before anyone has flipped is generally folly but if you wanna play that way, I won't kick and scream about it. You do you.
I like the insight we're getting to N1ed's thought process a lot, actually. The combined with the way he was frustrated my read on him wasn't stronger by now has definitely improved my opinion of the slot.
deletedover 8 years
mist could you talk about any changes in your reads from ~20 pages ago to now
The AtE from Ripple rang towny to me. I don't like that I townread it but I do. There was also this post
If we have a doctor and there not on impoe tonight I will honestly slap the taste out of your mouth
that when i read it, I had the feeling it was something Ripple wouldn't think to say as scum.
Yes.
Why is UltraAug above N1ed in your reads list?
HEY IAN PLEASE GIVE ME YOUR OWN READS LIST
Because he's townier.
i'd expect you to get more out of the second half of the game. why don't you think you have
deletedover 8 years
i was about to say something very flawed and I think it helped me point out my problem: I'm seeing this pretty linearly. in my eyes I NEED to have a scum and I NEED to be getting reads from them. i can see how that way of thinking is bad and I'm gonna try to fix that tbh
deletedover 8 years
The top is most likely to be town The bottom is most likely to be scum
Where exactly the categories fall is irrelevant. It could be "null" to "people I townread the most". It could be "Incredibly scummy" to "just a bit scummy". It could be "Mildly scummy" to "Mildly towny".
"could be". like dude, ily but it's your list. even if you don't love your reads 100% just say what's what. that's what I've been doing and I feel like I have a bit to work with now (39th page d1 reppin)
sorry for attacking you circa 25 pages or whatever i still think I'm right shh
You don't have to apologize for your reads, I'm OK with being pushed. And I appreciate that you're trying to create pressure. I don't label the reads on purpose, I can talk later on why that is if you like but I'm not going to for now.
understood. i don't like how much my play style is changing rn but I can respect that
those two statements I said were unrelated but in the same sentence w h a t
deletedover 8 years
EBWOP: i meant to respond, im sorry because that statement may have been unclear, but I can see almost any lynch taking place today. all I'm saying there is that I'd like to get some opinions on ripple (aka going down my read pool)
deletedover 8 years
another question that arises: if not mist, then who? i saw some good points on ripple a long while ago and thus came the read and then the potential team read
and Id like to elaborate on that???? loss of confidence: initiate
Maybe I'm misunderstanding but if you seriously feel everyone in this game besides me and maybe Ripple is unlynchable then I'm like, really confused.
deletedover 8 years
The top is most likely to be town The bottom is most likely to be scum
Where exactly the categories fall is irrelevant. It could be "null" to "people I townread the most". It could be "Incredibly scummy" to "just a bit scummy". It could be "Mildly scummy" to "Mildly towny".
"could be". like dude, ily but it's your list. even if you don't love your reads 100% just say what's what. that's what I've been doing and I feel like I have a bit to work with now (39th page d1 reppin)
sorry for attacking you circa 25 pages or whatever i still think I'm right shh
You don't have to apologize for your reads, I'm OK with being pushed. And I appreciate that you're trying to create pressure. I don't label the reads on purpose, I can talk later on why that is if you like but I'm not going to for now.
i think n1ed coudl be town though. Explain why aug is towny. I absolutely refuse to unvote aug until someone quotes a towny post from him and/or explains SOMETHING about their read.
as it is I think it's scummy that no one is considering him.
deletedover 8 years
another question that arises: if not mist, then who? i saw some good points on ripple a long while ago and thus came the read and then the potential team read
and Id like to elaborate on that???? loss of confidence: initiate
Maybe I'm misunderstanding but if you seriously feel everyone in this game besides me and maybe Ripple is unlynchable then I'm like, really confused.
deletedover 8 years
On N1ed, I discussed a bit how I had some reservations about his "townslips" and decided to write them off as null because the way he dropped them seemed like it was very possible for them to be faked but I'm not convinced they weren't real either. His read on me is odd and doesn't make much sense but I don't particularly think that's a scumtell coming from him. I'm curious to see how his reads progress though.
deletedover 8 years
another question that arises: if not mist, then who? i saw some good points on ripple a long while ago and thus came the read and then the potential team read
and Id like to elaborate on that???? loss of confidence: initiate
deletedover 8 years
mist could you talk about any changes in your reads from ~20 pages ago to now
The AtE from Ripple rang towny to me. I don't like that I townread it but I do. There was also this post
If we have a doctor and there not on impoe tonight I will honestly slap the taste out of your mouth
that when i read it, I had the feeling it was something Ripple wouldn't think to say as scum.
Yes.
Why is UltraAug above N1ed in your reads list?
HEY IAN PLEASE GIVE ME YOUR OWN READS LIST
Because he's townier.
deletedover 8 years
(ugh I'm such a band wagon player) but yeah i suppose ill back off on that read until I can support it. i know you guys are right but something feels off about it.
..
deletedover 8 years
Yes.
Why is UltraAug above N1ed in your reads list?
HEY IAN PLEASE GIVE ME YOUR OWN READS LIST
ive been meaning to ask you what your reads on me are, you didn't like my start but now you've seen a heck of a lot so yeah
N1ed, your read on me is objectively flawed. I'm sorry, I hate saying that in games because it feels like ad hoc, but please take a step back and really think about what you're saying. You're genuinely not making any sense and pushing of fallacies.
N1ed, your read on me is objectively flawed. I'm sorry, I hate saying that in games because it feels like ad hoc, but please take a step back and really think about what you're saying. You're genuinely not making any sense and pushing of fallacies.
N1ed, your read on me is objectively flawed. I'm sorry, I hate saying that in games because it feels like ad hoc, but please take a step back and really think about what you're saying. You're genuinely not making any sense and pushing of fallacies.
N1ed, your read on me is objectively flawed. I'm sorry, I hate saying that in games because it feels like ad hoc, but please take a step back and really think about what you're saying. You're genuinely not making any sense and pushing of fallacies.
I agree. I didn't see one valid point from N1ed, and this is coming from someone who does NOT tr mist.
He's asking others to explain their TR's, yet justifying his STRONGEST READ read in FM with "gut." That itself is an actual fallacy.
deletedover 8 years
The top is most likely to be town The bottom is most likely to be scum
Where exactly the categories fall is irrelevant. It could be "null" to "people I townread the most". It could be "Incredibly scummy" to "just a bit scummy". It could be "Mildly scummy" to "Mildly towny".
"could be". like dude, ily but it's your list. even if you don't love your reads 100% just say what's what. that's what I've been doing and I feel like I have a bit to work with now (39th page d1 reppin)
sorry for attacking you circa 25 pages or whatever i still think I'm right shh
N1ed, your read on me is objectively flawed. I'm sorry, I hate saying that in games because it feels like ad hoc, but please take a step back and really think about what you're saying. You're genuinely not making any sense and pushing of fallacies.
okay look, I'm not 100% confident in what I'm saying, but I feel as if I'm trying to get something going (idk what we'd be talking about rn if this wasn't happening tbh), and honestly I still kind of believe it, even if I can't 100% prove it. IDK FML okay well on the off chance that we are the same alignment, I suppose I should really get focused on the game as a whole tb