Hey guys welcome to Forum Mafia 16 with your hosts Sonia and Gerry! sign up below (kudos to mist for using her rules thing)
The Mafia have won!
I. The Schedule:
72 hour days and 24 hour nights.
If the majority of night actions have not been submitted by the end of the night, I will extend the night another 12 hours. This will only occur once per night at most.
II. The Setup:
(Changes from previous forum mafia games are in bold)
Normal closed roles setup, as always, with the roles and affixes listed below
By default there are no Night 1 actions, including the mafia kill.
By default no role can self visit, except watcher.
Players are always notified at day start if their role is changed.
Players who share a meeting may communicate outside the game at any time of day.
**
One mafia makes the kill each night. They will be the only one to visit the target.
On death, players flip their full role by default.
Members of the mafia may both make their role action as well as the factional kill on the same night.
Please note the addition of the Twilight phase (in short, discussion after the hammer has occurred is now allowed until I am present to begin the night phase). Also, supermajority rules are in effect with no time limit.
also
Editing your posts is not allowed. Use the EBWOP function (Edit By Way of Post) if you need to restate something or fix a spelling error.
V. Game Mechanics:
Meetings between players (mafia, masons, templars) will be facilitated in whatever way is most convenient for the players, as long as I can access these communications. Skype, Discord, QuickTopics, or Private Messages which include the moderators are all fine.
Votes must be made in the format Vote: Playername. Bolding is done using the tags [b][/b].
I'm starting to think n1ed might seem naturally awkward / forced because even though he initially came off like that, the more I read his lines the more I townread him.
Editing your posts is not allowed. Use the EBWOP function (Edit By Way of Post) if you need to restate something or fix a spelling error.
sonia im lookin at you here
deletedover 8 years
my game notes:
ultra towny good jeffrey??? idk
shrub is another idk hang on ian is claiming pr again and that's null but it gave me a towny vibe idk papu gives me bad papu vibes LOL wait solace actually kind of reminds me of mist last game so im gonna automatically tr that lolrip ya idk i really kinda tr ultra gj bud sonia is host shrub is gonna stay null for now ok
gerry is host actually pony reminds me of my beginning like, last game. slight tr for you good sir bad feeling from jeff???? idk more to develop on this story soon THANK U SODA FOR EXPLAINING RVS okay anyway slightly slight town vibe nice townier vibe from justdance aka ian???? idk sure mist said hi how do i read into this
okay that was per page and i was gonna go on to page 5 but i have a luminous feeling (word choice??) that im gonna hit character limit so idk
Yes, mafia do force content to be townread, but I don't think any scum would openly reveal that they had been forcing tells. This isn't something that papuito normally does in regular mafia games. In fact, I think papuito is playing quite a bit differently as opposed to his normal games. But this is a whole new ballgame and I don't think people are expected to have the same metagames as they do in to quote Retti "Ruby Mafia".
His content IS actually forced, but he's admitted that it was forced, and I don't think that scum would admit that they forced posts to be townread. I think pap just wants to be townread and not lynched. [/quote]but isnt forcing content to be townread something mafia would try to do?
maybe im just stupid but this is one of my reads that seems logical to me
of course i havent played with pap before does pap usually do this bs
deletedover 8 years
And my T>S list taking out the two nulls
deletedover 8 years
I f'd up the alphabetization of my reads :(((( Anyways,
Reads on everyone:
JeffreyAaron:
Justdance666:
Minecraft:
Mist:
Mori:
N1ed:
Papuito:
PonyLove:
Shrub:
soda:
Solace:
UltraAug
Which then leads to my vote
Vote: Mori
deletedover 8 years
UltraAug
I think my read on this dude has flipped the most but I'm ultimately gonna lean town on him for now.
I'll give some scumtells and towntells from him.
Scumtells:
Potential forced interactions with JeffreyAaron, his beginning was pretty bleh.
I don't understand why he felt the need to defend me, I really don't think I had done much to deserve such defense.
Possible contradiction given that justdance had voted at the time he said that, but I think he was referring to jd666 SRing papuito here.
I think that his vote on papuito was also pretty bad. He had fosed papuito for a while and only voted him once he started to gain momentum. However, here's the thing. I do not think that Mori+UltraAug are on a team due to UltraAug blatantly following her vote so one or none of them are scum, and given the reads I've given on Mori he's probably just the town here that didn't know when to vote.
Towntells:
deletedover 8 years
PonyLove
I did initially say that PonyLove was probably very likely town however, she gave a read on mist that was pretty dumb. Mist only made two posts which were "hi" and a vote on me. I don't know if Pony scumreads mist because she townreads me or what but that read makes no sense.
However here's some towntells from her.
I pondered the same thing, just approached Solace in a different way.
This was a good post encouraging Jeff to actively participate and I actually liked her vote that went along with it.
soda
A pretty rad lad.
Solace
I don't understand why everyone TRs the out of Solace because I really don't. The reason I voted him initially was because of his awful, unnecessary townread on N1ed. Then he instantly OMGUSed me which I actually slightly townread. But I'm not gonna mark Solace as town solely for OMGUSing me.
Shrub
I think this dude is town because I think his question about how many mafia there were was genuine. I also think his vote on Mori was pretty good as a vote to gauge reaction. We did get a pretty terrible reaction from Mori. He acknowledged this, most likely, and thusly has kept his vote.
deletedover 8 years
Minecraftfangirlftw
Still a better mafia player than Stove.
mist
No read on her yet for obvious reasons, voted me at the beginning of the day which is potential RVS but probably not.
N1ed
If I had a gun to my head, he'd be town, but that's just a gun to my head read. It's too early to make a call on him when he's offered so little.
papuito
Pap's actually my strongest townread, and he's been a controversial player so I'd like to explain why I believe he is town this game. His content IS actually forced, but he's admitted that it was forced, and I don't think that scum would admit that they forced posts to be townread. I think pap just wants to be townread and not lynched. I think pap's responses to people voting him were all really towny.
deletedover 8 years
I don't think N1ed's intro was very alignment indicative, her read on N1ed looks like one she put on the back burner to push on later because no one ever actively pursued a lynch like they did on papuito.
I think out of all 3 votes on papuito that were mafde over the course of the game (jd666, UA, Mori) hers was the worst. She scumreads pap for "filler" which she should know is non-alignment indicative, and personally I don't really think that papuito has fillered that much. It looks like a weak vote she put on someone who could easily gain momentum so she could skate through another day.
Her townread on Solace was pretty bad, but maybe that's just because I find him scummy and I'll explain why later. This could potentially be Mori buddying Solace with him being either alignment. I think what she said about him was complete BS. Solace hasn't really analyzed the game as much as Mori says he has, and he's definitely not the one that's contributed the most.
Her reaction to Shrub voting her was pretty bad.
Her null-read on UltraAug is pretty stupid as well. In my opinion, UltraAug has given us the most tells so far this game and her defense on him looks a little bit forced.
deletedover 8 years
Mori
Has only made one post thus far into the game. I appreciate that she's trying, but I did not like the content she had to offer.
deletedover 8 years
JeffreyAaron
Jeff's content was pretty much non-alignment indicative for the most part. The interactions with him and UltraAug in the beginning were possibly forced. Another thing that strikes me odd is that he got moderately defensive over PonyLove outing a scumread on him for filler. He used reasons from a past game to not actively participate as much. It definitely sticks out to me but I can see it being something done by both alignments so it's not super alignment telling.
justdance666
I've noticed that justdance666 likes to vote tons of people to gauge reaction so he can create proper reads. Him voting all over the place wasn't super scummy to me, mainly because it's him. If it were someone else it might be scummy but in his case, it's not alignment indicative. I said his vote on pap was pretty bad because in my opinion pap was town, I didn't imply whether or not I scumread him for voting papuito in which I don't. I read the reasons why he voted papuito and they seem pretty genuine, to be honest. I just don't agree with them, and I'll explain why.
