over 8 years

Sign-ups are now closed. Roles are being sent out, the game starts at 12:00 AM EST on Monday, June 13.

If you wish to be a substitution, please PM this account.


Here's some guidelines to the game courtesy of mist:

http://pastebin.com/kEUDw4T9


Sample Role PM:

Welcome to Forum Mafia 17, Matt.

Your role is Vanilla Townie, sided with the town.

Your only power in this game is your voice and your vote. Good luck.

You win when all threats to the town are eliminated.


Scumhunt your heart this game out if you're town or towntell like none other if you're not, because the player that Jeff and I feel plays the best game will receive a 20 token prize!!!

over 8 years
Since Mori retracts, it means Dorzel is almost 100% PR. I'm ruling him out being mafia at all at this point. I want to say that izzy was on Mori since she told Mori to be on Dorzel. So I want to say Mori is town.

Here are my reads currently:

Dorzel: Town
Mori Town
Minecraftfangirlftw: Leaning Town
Shrub: Null Leaning Mafia
papuito: Mafia

Now, before we vote, I want everyone to be able to talk a bit more. I'm still not ruling out that we have 2 mafs left here.

I say this because Mafia has 2 goons. Usually it would be like 3 maf PR and 1 goon if there are 4 mafs. But, with 5 it could be 3 maf PR and 2 goons. BUT I should stress this. Because there is a killer there could just be 2 maf PR and 2 goons.
over 8 years
Okay, there is a couple things I need to say.

1st: No one vote.

2nd: Damn, izzy was my hard tr, so it sucks she died.

3rd: I've already figured out what happened. Alright so, izzy was most likely the role called "Town Backup" It's basically an amnesic is on EM. They can take a role from the GY, and assume that role. I have mix feelings about what izzy did. Because, now that I think about it, she coulda caused auto win for us potentially, but there are two scenarios we need to think about

3A: One, that she died saving someone from town. Most likely Mori or Dorzel. I think that she was on Mori in this scenario, because she asked the watcher to be on Dorzel so mafia couldn't kill thinking there was a Watcher on Dorzel, so they tried to kill the watcher (Mori).

3B: She actually DIDN'T die saving someone. And someone night killed her (which would be the worst scenario) As that means mafia most likely has a role where they can determine roles? Or maybe a tracker of their own?

I think the first case scenario is more likely based on a few reasons. I think mafia would try and kill a PR unless they KNEW izzy was a PR, and since they had a role cop, idk.

4. I think izzy prob should have taken Orc (Or role cop? If that's possible? But EM is laggy so I can't check if taking a mafia role is possible) instead of BG and claimed a PR role, but I guess she didn't think it was worth it, or couldn't think of a PR to claim that was not orc (cause she wouldn't die)

5. I am glad that Mori retracted because if she didn't one of the PRs was 100% fake. And I was going to say her over Dorzel. But, I wasn't sure. I think even IF Mori is mafia, her best bet was retracting here.

6. Since Dorzel is almost confirmed town. I'm going to set my lynch targets in Papuito, Shrub. There is a least 1 mafia in there from my analysis. But, as I said don't vote.

I hope this post clears up why there were "2 bodyguards"
over 8 years
Okay, going to post something I had typed up for when EM worked again.
over 8 years

Dorzel says

*25 Minutes to say that*


uh no
over 8 years
*25 Minutes to say that*
over 8 years
shrub: you say the pap is obvious, he is because pony might had wifomed for their partner(s) or he bussed in a last ditch effort (idk bout forum maf but once in comp i saw this person hard buss when they were obvious maf and won because they "would never do that"
over 8 years

Dorzel says

Yea basically saying you don't wanna lynch the person you are buddying, the person who is sorta clear and yourself. If you are gonna buddy someone you gotta go full steam ahead on that one


im not trying to buddy shrub ;-; well i should say "im not buddying shrub"
over 8 years
Yea basically saying you don't wanna lynch the person you are buddying, the person who is sorta clear and yourself. If you are gonna buddy someone you gotta go full steam ahead on that one
over 8 years
is everyone dead, did em go down again? i
over 8 years
basically im open to lynch anyone but me, my tr and the clear lmao i understand why u said that now (i prefer to lynch pap tho)
over 8 years

Dorzel says

Right now i feel like your mentality is:
Lynch anyone but me


uh excuse me i want a lynch on anyone but shrub u and me shrub i just thought about things and realized WHY WAS I TR ING MORI OVER SHRUB???????????????? Shrub= No.1 tr atm
over 8 years
also im worried i legit think there is 2 maf alive and i dont know who well pap + someone uh pranay forum maf had 17 players and 5 mafs so uh i think thats whats worrying me the most
over 8 years
Right now i feel like your mentality is:
Lynch anyone but me
over 8 years
If you want an honest answer, i didn't see it. Reason: I don't care
over 8 years
also i would like to not be lynched in possible mylo thank you very much
over 8 years

Dorzel says

Is it weird if i think Gerry's claim is fake because 6 power roles is a little too much for my liking? But today i wanna get Minecraft


why did u not answer my question earlier? (who would u lynch apart from pap and me)
over 8 years
shrub no matter what u think about me (aka me noob) my tr for u still stands :P
over 8 years
Is it weird if i think Gerry's claim is fake because 6 power roles is a little too much for my liking? But today i wanna get Minecraft
over 8 years
Sorry for being inactive recently tho but gj on lynching mafia without me!
over 8 years

Minecraftfangirlftw says


Shrub says


Mori says

I'm pretty sure she died saving either me or Dorzel. Mostly Dorzel. Because she asked me to be on Dorzel. She probably thought Dorzel was gonna die.

Now it's time for me to admit I am not watcher. I am just a blue who wanted to die in place of the actual PRs. I thought if I claimed watcher I would bait mafia into killing me over other PRs (who turned out to be non-investigative).


Alright so you must townread the absolute f*ck out of me for my push on you. As mafia or blue i would have no information about your role and so the fact that i did that shows i have towny intent.

Don't even try and push on me after that.


shrub your already really towny m8 your in my town circle (not like it matters) probs my second tr after mori (not counting dorzel over there who is one shot vig therefore clear)


it really doesnt matter whether you townread me or not.
over 8 years
I feel like its pap at this current time though.

Note: I'm speaking like its one left because i think its one left.
over 8 years
Comprehensive reads list:
town -> mafia
Shrub: yay me
Dorzel: Cleared. or at least i am not considering he is mafia.
Gerry: Has towntold a metric ton recently. Now my third strongest pr claim coupled with his softs and towntells.

Mori and mine:
I would not be surprised if one of these 2 is mafia tbh. I dont like the fact that Mori claimed watcher. Shoot me but i dont. Hypocritical, i know. I feel like their explination is i guessss plausible but it just doesnt seem like a play they would make as town. I guess its definately more likely than they are mafia just because of the rest of their game. I didnt like their reaction to me noticing how fake their watcher claim was, but i did like the way they reaction tested me.
I'm starting to doubt that mine is actually town. They continue to do f*ck all and slightly towntell but i think they are also scumtelling a bit. I dont like the way they seemingly randomly vote on every fcking bw for reasons like "this votes catching" but i know thats just mine being bad. Difficult read.
Pap.
Now that Pony flipped mafia I'm sorta not sure about you. I think that her defence of you before when she outed sr on you then didnt want to vote you might have actually been just too obvious. It seemed like Pony was setting you up to be lynched. I definately scumred Pony over you (shoot me for not switching votes i had work and no internet at home). From POE i GUESS you are mafia, but I'm ready to be convinced by some slick towntells.

Overall, I'm open to any of Mori mine and pap being mafia.
over 8 years
Yea there is the village then i am the weirdo in the corner
over 8 years

Shrub says


Mori says

I'm pretty sure she died saving either me or Dorzel. Mostly Dorzel. Because she asked me to be on Dorzel. She probably thought Dorzel was gonna die.

Now it's time for me to admit I am not watcher. I am just a blue who wanted to die in place of the actual PRs. I thought if I claimed watcher I would bait mafia into killing me over other PRs (who turned out to be non-investigative).


Alright so you must townread the absolute f*ck out of me for my push on you. As mafia or blue i would have no information about your role and so the fact that i did that shows i have towny intent.

Don't even try and push on me after that.


shrub your already really towny m8 your in my town circle (not like it matters) probs my second tr after mori (not counting dorzel over there who is one shot vig therefore clear)
over 8 years

Mori says

I'm pretty sure she died saving either me or Dorzel. Mostly Dorzel. Because she asked me to be on Dorzel. She probably thought Dorzel was gonna die.

Now it's time for me to admit I am not watcher. I am just a blue who wanted to die in place of the actual PRs. I thought if I claimed watcher I would bait mafia into killing me over other PRs (who turned out to be non-investigative).


Alright so you must townread the absolute f*ck out of me for my push on you. As mafia or blue i would have no information about your role and so the fact that i did that shows i have towny intent.

Don't even try and push on me after that.