over 8 years

Sign-ups are now closed. Roles are being sent out, the game starts at 12:00 AM EST on Monday, June 13.

If you wish to be a substitution, please PM this account.


Here's some guidelines to the game courtesy of mist:

http://pastebin.com/kEUDw4T9


Sample Role PM:

Welcome to Forum Mafia 17, Matt.

Your role is Vanilla Townie, sided with the town.

Your only power in this game is your voice and your vote. Good luck.

You win when all threats to the town are eliminated.


Scumhunt your heart this game out if you're town or towntell like none other if you're not, because the player that Jeff and I feel plays the best game will receive a 20 token prize!!!

over 8 years
thank you dorzel for at least not making me your number one sr (after the unmovable dorzel rereads im not longer his number one sr) CELEBRATION TIME!
over 8 years

Shrub says


papuito says

Well to be perfectly honest with you i almost rather die than her but i rather you die then both of us. I think i have been towny and my actions support it. Dorzel/Mine i recommend you reread your townread if not it will severely hurt the town. Also i should be annoyed for gerry not explaining why he is "clear" but ill forgive him since he said i could have the last piece of bread today.


vote shrub

im pretty sure based on towns currents reads im gonna die so your welcome for helping with pony and your welcome for leading on shrub.


honestly this vote has cast away any doubt i had about your alignment.


Sorry but what do you expect? Like seriously
over 8 years
55- People townread the Mom get the camera line, a reusing of that. Mine saying they have no reads or they are bad and it is hard to make reads (Which i disagree with, i think they are a solid player and all) then giving out a massive list of reads with reasons such as "They scumtold" or "They towntold". I think Minecraftfangirlftw is mafia because they scumtold.
56- Asking people why they townread her and not wanting anyone else to elaborate on their read on others
60- Literally opening the front door so i can scumread them
64- Mine voting without a reason or elaborated reasoning
I tended to notice how people were very confident in their reads, defending their townreads to the death or whatever. Also the mafia, not including Arcbell as a third party killer, never outed a long list of reads which i think makes Papuito & Gerry look slightly worse and Mine, Mori and Shrub look better.
If you would like to know why i have any of the reads feel free to ask me :)-This by MCFG Is towny (Sidenote: Most of their reads were town, like using some basic prediction there is not gonna be 1 mafia...)
Mori13d 56m
My assumption is

1) mafia

2) vig

3) Arcbell
Mori being very accurate is FISH, but i am gonna take it as they are a very good player
Minecraftfangirlftw13d 50m
Mori
Dorzel has a towny aura but that can be faked as mafia
i agree i used to have tr on him but then i thought about it a bit more and realized how faked it can be
That is literally staying with Mori to be protected in their towncircle. Without second doubting Mori.
Pages 70-80
Papuito said they would look at stuff on the weekend, why not now?
over 8 years

papuito says

Well to be perfectly honest with you i almost rather die than her but i rather you die then both of us. I think i have been towny and my actions support it. Dorzel/Mine i recommend you reread your townread if not it will severely hurt the town. Also i should be annoyed for gerry not explaining why he is "clear" but ill forgive him since he said i could have the last piece of bread today.


vote shrub

im pretty sure based on towns currents reads im gonna die so your welcome for helping with pony and your welcome for leading on shrub.


honestly this vote has cast away any doubt i had about your alignment.
over 8 years
Well to be perfectly honest with you i almost rather die than her but i rather you die then both of us. I think i have been towny and my actions support it. Dorzel/Mine i recommend you reread your townread if not it will severely hurt the town. Also i should be annoyed for gerry not explaining why he is "clear" but ill forgive him since he said i could have the last piece of bread today.


vote shrub

im pretty sure based on towns currents reads im gonna die so your welcome for helping with pony and your welcome for leading on shrub.
over 8 years
30-31 -Mori actively scumhunting
33- I want to pay particular attention to the interactions between Happy and Mine. Shrub also getting mad at getting fosed, as if they have had nothing scummy, implying they have actively KNOWN they have done nothing scummy
36-Mine says it is hard to tell jokes from real stuff yet later brings it up how they made obvious jokes, from self experience they should give more lenience on that one
44-Mine not wanting to fight a power role claim, as in believing they are real however states "Pr" in quotes meaning they don't believe it is real. Gerry wanted to lynch GHD(Ponylove).
46-Antikirst wanted to sacrifice a player for alignment tells on others
47-Antikirst wanting people to elaborate on their reads
50-
Quoted from Shrub
Mori scumhunting a ton
Mori: very strong townread, her content has been consistently good and reasonable. She is definately actively scum hunting and trying to find Mafia which I townread. It would take very good Mafia play to pull this of.
Minecraftfangirl: I think she is town as this seems like her town game, the only way you can read minecraft as an alignment is meta as she consistently scum tells - at least to me - as both alignments.
Sonia: I think they are town (whoa reads switch) there willingness to prove they are town and solid towny answers to my questioning has led to me TOWNREADING them. I also like the confidence in which they voted me after my towny but forced line. They definately scumtold to begin with but have been getting consistently better since then.
Sidenote: Something i noticed was that Mine was never fosed by anyone, they played a casual sitting the fence by having all townreads and not committing to anything leaving their options open. They also never asked people to elaborate on their reads on other people.
over 8 years
Unvote Minecraftfangirlftw
over 8 years

papuito says

woah woah woah I need to make my case and i can't believe gerry would vote me without telling me so sneaky. So i thought about it alot and like people have been towny by what they say but not quite with what they do. I literally went out of my way to read peoples other games just for meta for this yet im voted. I literally also voted ponylove who btw shrub you were wondering why she didn't vote me its because she tends to not vote me in games unless im like confirmed and thats because of our friendship and it actually helps me in games and i think gerry who is also close to her knows what im talking about.. Anyways If i had to vote which i feel like i do then im voting shrub it could be gerry but if i had hammer i would do shrub. mechanically he hasn't been towny at all this game they are just strong because they are super demanding. Also I want a promise from anyone who votes me to not vote mori if there is a tomorrow.


absolutely not.
over 8 years
woah woah woah I need to make my case and i can't believe gerry would vote me without telling me so sneaky. So i thought about it alot and like people have been towny by what they say but not quite with what they do. I literally went out of my way to read peoples other games just for meta for this yet im voted. I literally also voted ponylove who btw shrub you were wondering why she didn't vote me its because she tends to not vote me in games unless im like confirmed and thats because of our friendship and it actually helps me in games and i think gerry who is also close to her knows what im talking about.. Anyways If i had to vote which i feel like i do then im voting shrub it could be gerry but if i had hammer i would do shrub. mechanically he hasn't been towny at all this game they are just strong because they are super demanding. Also I want a promise from anyone who votes me to not vote mori if there is a tomorrow.
over 8 years
Vote pap minecraftfangirl.
over 8 years
Voting Log
papuito (2) Shrub Gerry
Minecraftfangirlftw (1) Dorzel
Gerry (0)
Dorzel (0)
Mori (0)
Shrub (0)
Not voting (3) Mori papuito Minecraftfangirlftw

is this right?
over 8 years
my vote log is so outdated im gonna update it brb
over 8 years
Vote: Papuito
over 8 years
Page 5: i was seriously worried about the gun i also cant tell jokes from real things (sonia claiming mastermind and etc) Page 6: i wanted to be mled so i could avoid doing what im doing right now (trying sort of hard to not get lynched in possible mylo
Page 10: I tried my best to towntell i dont know what you mean by "implying town"
Page 11: i had tr on happy back then i full-heartedly admit that i thought happy was town until yoyo fliped me also i doubt that there is a third left to be honest also i pretty much rely on meta
Page 13: thats happy i dont know why u brought that up please explain further
Page 14: Shrub already pointed that out and i DO have bad wording a lot and rest of the town did not say that was a "slip" so have fun with me in comp games and stuff i do that a lot
Page 15: i really dont think you should judge pap with what anti does well i mean that worked on ponylove but still its a bit unfair gerry was doing good then
Page 23: Tbh i thought it was a normal shrub thing so i thought nothing of it
over 8 years

Dorzel says

I am actually going to put effort in so here goes starting from day five.
Page 5-MCFG Worried about a gun, reasonable reaction
6-MCFG Asking to be shot after saying "gun" as if it did not exist and later as if it did exist. Asking to be shot well...
10-MCFG Implying town
11-MCFG Using meta as a reason to townread themselves. Also did not fully read or understand my part of "Not town" compared to "Mafia". That implies a third party role or hostile role, it was one in happy/MCFG, no need to react as if it was solely on you.
13-Shrub's Meta reads concerning
*Noticed how everytime a fos was placed on Happy they responded with "What a horrible read on me"*
Page 14-MCFG Slips (In my opinion) Saying "It is hard for me to do it as town anyways" implying they are not doing it as town in the present.
15-Antikirst giving solid information and opinions on people
Gerry being proactive and keeping town moving in the right direction, following their earlier statement of wanting to win and town doing well.
23-Shrub outing a retraction with a simple explanation but nobody reacted and replaced votes on them.
25-Shrub+Antikirst both giving solid input
Gonna do more later :3 Hope my opinion helps in any way possible


here goes nothing,
over 8 years
ok sorry i was locked out because This computer was registered by Oczkowski. Please try again in 1 hour (dont even know who that person is) anyways i dont know if em is working for you guys but im really tempted to reply to dorzel trying to fos me yet again
over 8 years
Due to the website being DDOS'ed, today's day will end when supermajority is reached whether that's in the form of one person being lynched, or a no lynch being achieved.
over 8 years

Gerry says

imma just guess we get like an extra day or 2 because of all the EM bs

over 8 years
imma just guess we get like an extra day or 2 because of all the EM bs
over 8 years
Lynch papuito today.
over 8 years
Right now DORZEL is the most towny followed by Gerry and MCFG and Mori and papuito are scum.
over 8 years
What a meme you use my line against me.
over 8 years

Mori says

There's a great contradiction between the things you say and the things you do.

over 8 years

Mori says

Saying that Gerry and I are mafia together IS a ridiculous read. And having incredibly accurate reads does not mean you are town, as mafia, you would be informed enough for that. Especially since you never really pushed on the scumreads who ended up being mafia (imsohappy and thirdaug at the very least)


This is actually the first decent point she has made,

I didn't push in thirdAug because I was against lynching an AFK. Although he had meta scumtold in his lines I still didn't want to lynch an ISP. This is have said a lot.

I wasn't SURE happy was Mafia, and I wanted Gerry to claim because I basically read him as pr/Mafia. Gerry as a blue claim was more scummy than happy as a blue claim, at least to me. I still voted them...
over 8 years

Mori says

Also you can vote me, idgaf. If you are town and you are going to blindly vote me, disregarding everything I do and say which shows I'm town, then sure, let's lose.


This line is completely pointless. Absolutely nothing but an attempt at a forced towntell.