cinnanie says

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2TdiNs2bE9A

since this is a cover, i obviously won't judge based on songwriting or composition since they had no involvement in it, but rather interpretation.

interpretation: 7/10
his softer tone really suits the lyrics better, and it flows better
vocals: 9/10
his voice is superb.

overall: 8. it's great.

colours says

wat about this

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tv9YoYCKNoE

*im not gonna go into detail with each rating anymore bc this is a lot

songwriting: 3/10
basic
composition: 3/10
the instrumentals cloud the voice
vocals: 6/10
its ok.

overall: 4/10

it unsettles me every time you use my name on this site

ima do everything else tmr. zzz

im beginning to see a pattern in my songs...

HardCarry says

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fBrOwiHO-5w

songwriting: 10/10
the raw poetic elements and sound devices used in the lyrics are top-notch, phenomenal, great, amazing, lovely, soothes my poetic brain. great approach with the message
composition: 8/10
nothing special that stands out musically but love the instruments boi for that upbeat vibe iykwim. i hate synthesized instruments so this is definitely a good thing.. smh.
vocals: 10/10
giving anything lower than a 10 would not do them justice. so unique.. @everyone listen to this to see what i mean.

overall: 9.3/10, would definitely deserve a 9.5~10

wat about this

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tv9YoYCKNoE

Azure says

https://youtu.be/kzQTc0-iBX8 xd

ok... i'll start this by saying i love halsey to death but this single did not do her justice.
songwriting: 3/10
compared to her room 93 EP or Badlands album these lyrics are a MAJOR downgrade, i can't even think of a more repetitive writing style with absolutely zero relatability or thought going into it- i get that it's pop... but still.
composition: 2/10
this had never been her strong suit but for a very basic rhythm, again, annoyingly repetitive. the progression doesn't stray off too far from what she'd done before though.. it's her style
vocals: 4/10
i only like autotune when it's done well.

overall: 3/10 sry halsey

https://youtu.be/kzQTc0-iBX8 xd

ImDory says

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bnVUHWCynig

not going to be biased but
songwriting 10/10
composition 10/10
vocals 10/10

overall 10/10

colours says

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9U4ZPs6Eyus

songwriting: 7/10
not much to say here other than the fact that the lyrics are great for a theme that can be considered a bit overdone
composition: 4/10
very basic predictable melody with a just as basic chord progression
vocals: 9/10
this is the saving grace of this song, his vocal color and technique is so UGGH why does it remind me of hayley wlms (a teenybit)???
overall: 6.6/10 + 1 for the very *cute* bridge = 7.6

jk i used to listen 2 a lot of slipknot back when i was more emo than i am no w

hedger says

are you sure you don't want any slipknot?

shoulda tied it better

are you sure you don't want any slipknot?