Oracle was worse about it, but you were definately using rhetoric like "so he HAS to be mafia" etc and arguing that I couldn't be town given the circumstances. Also this is possibly the first online argument I've had that has stayed civil so I removed the -K.
I certainly agree that suiciding is wrong. I had no part in that, and I never intentionally suicide in ranked. -K him for it, by all means.
As for lying, feel free to lie about your role, reports, etc, when it has to do with something in THAT ROUND. What I'm talking about is how you two deceived him on how the game's mechanics work. You aren't on a trophy run, so I don't think your 55 more pointless points are worth confusing new players about how the game works.