Back to Forum Games

Forum Mafia I - Tarot Mafia

deletedover 6 years

Rules - https://pastebin.com/G9d1ehn7

Setup Notes:

  • 72 hour days, 24 hour nights.

  • This setup is role madness; everyone will be a power role.

  • This game will be for 13 players; 10 will be town and 3 will be mafia.

  • I will be using Natural Action Resolution.

  • Day start duh

Any other questions please comment below.... Or if you are interested

I fugged up and forgot to add game mode

Spadez0 has replaced carmen give her a warm welcome

Arachnid replaced elfen, welcome arachnid :)

Lets give Pinks (replacing Htennis) a warm welcome

GAME LOG

Page 4 - GAME BEGINS

Page 19 - Day 1 Ends - No one was lynched

Page 19 - Day 2 Begins - No one has been killed

Page 71 - Day 2 Ends - Happeh was Lynched

Page 71 - Day 3 Begins - TownOfSalemRox has been killed

Page 79 - Day 3 Ends - Denial was Lynched

Page 79 - Day 4 Begins - IChaotic was killed

Page 98 - Day 4 Ends - No one was lynched

Page 98 - Day 5 Begins - Ghost13 was killed

Page 99 - Day 5 Ends - Arrogate was Lynched

Page 99 - Day 6 Begins - Lesbian Pirate was Killed

Page 107 - Day 6 ends - No one was lynched

Page 107 - Day 5 begins - Arachnid has fallen

Page 11 - Town Loses - they were in autoloss and knew they were in autoloss

deletedover 6 years

Pinks says

Wait so why would Happeh reveal to us she gets to shoot someone at night if she's mafia?


ToS outted me - he has a 1 shot role reveal
shady
over 6 years

Pinks says

Wait so why would Happeh reveal to us she gets to shoot someone at night if she's mafia?


she was investigated by role cop and HE outed her
deletedover 6 years
I’m gonna respond in the most vague way so as not to put anything

The reason I needed to change the way the RB worked is because it relates to how night one played out and going back would have been not impossible (it would’ve been easy) but it would’ve been a direct impact to the game in a negative way

If the mafia who is killing is RB’d then the kill fails

I’ve been cramming for a big organic chem exam that is in 15 minutes and I’m sorry for that
Pinks
over 6 years
Wait so why would Happeh reveal to us she gets to shoot someone at night if she's mafia?
deletedover 6 years

shady says

denial don't you think that's a good point about what Birbtales said at the time though. I feel like if you had roleblocked mafia he would have fking said so


he wouldnt have made his initial mistake
shady
over 6 years
what did you clarify here denial? What conversation did you have with Birbtales in private


denial says

oh.. umm ok I guess I should go clarify something with him



denial says

k so nevermind, it'll work like em where roleblocker can only stop a kill if one maf is alive

so maf either NKed, a doc saved, or somebody vested was hit

carry on, just means happehs role is a lot more stronger comparatively than i thought before (to my own role)

deletedover 6 years
mayhaps start getting votes on Spadez?
deletedover 6 years

TownOfSalemRox says


Birbtales says

I made a mistake and Im gonna admit that and you all can feel free to shame me but for the sake of continuing without doing a bunch of shlt over, 1 mafia visits the kill and they can be roleblocked


If Happeh led the kill then she is mafia, but her role is very powerful, so I'm not sure she would have led...


hey someone who makes sense
denial
over 6 years
He didn't read what I was saying. He just saw the @ and responded to that. Hes been missing votes cause hes skimming for @s and bolds
deletedover 6 years

iChaotic says

The fact that no night kills were present and he knew Happeh’s roleblock meant nothing at the time that basically invalidates denails push on Happeh since he didnt know this at the time. The mod just learning that the kill doesn’t go through means this is recent knowledge e not a couple days ago in the night knowledge

deletedover 6 years

iChaotic says

Btw the mod indirectly confirmed that Happeh was town when he said the kill would Still go through. That means denials roleblock on happeh did not change anything that occured during the night or he would have initially said what he just told us now.

shady
over 6 years
denial don't you think that's a good point about what Birbtales said at the time though. I feel like if you had roleblocked mafia he would have fking said so
denial
over 6 years
TOSR, VOTE HER. YOU DISAPPEAR BEFORE HAMMER TIME. I NEED YOUR VOTE NOW.
shady
over 6 years

Ghost13 says

quick question if you rb one mafia shouldn't the kill still go through or is that not a thing here



Birbtales says

The kill will still go through

shady
over 6 years
ok let me look at what he said specifically regarding this
denial
over 6 years

iChaotic says

Btw the mod indirectly confirmed that Happeh was town when he said the kill would Still go through. That means denials roleblock on happeh did not change anything that occured during the night or he would have initially said what he just told us now.


That doesnt confirm anything u monkey.

Not only would that never confirm she was town (because her pr abilities already confirm her as mafia but some of you are too dense to see), but he was responding to ghosts question at the time on if one role block could stop 3 mafia from visiting a kill
shady
over 6 years
unvote happeh

aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa motherfk I hate this
shady
over 6 years
ah maybe that is true
TownOfSalemRox
over 6 years

Birbtales says

I made a mistake and Im gonna admit that and you all can feel free to shame me but for the sake of continuing without doing a bunch of shlt over, 1 mafia visits the kill and they can be roleblocked


If Happeh led the kill then she is mafia, but her role is very powerful, so I'm not sure she would have led...
iChaotic
over 6 years
The fact that no night kills were present and he knew Happeh’s roleblock meant nothing at the time that basically invalidates denails push on Happeh since he didnt know this at the time. The mod just learning that the kill doesn’t go through means this is recent knowledge e not a couple days ago in the night knowledge
shady
over 6 years

iChaotic says

Btw the mod indirectly confirmed that Happeh was town when he said the kill would Still go through. That means denials roleblock on happeh did not change anything that occured during the night or he would have initially said what he just told us now.


yeahhh dude I don't know, I was thinking about that.
shady
over 6 years
look at that I started off just saying what I was thinking and convinced myself to vote i'm a g
shady
over 6 years
I'm kind of stressed about this right now, I think the best thing to do would just be say what I'm thinking.

denial is forcing the issue between him and happeh. He has gone so far as to call them ccs. I don't think this is inherently alignment telling, but I think it's an important context to view the game in.

I think denial's argument of Happeh's role not fitting in a balanced town makes sense, especially looking at old games. I think that since there was no kill and we now know that denial had the power to roleblock a kill, the most simple and obvious solution is that he stopped Happeh from killing. Since we don't know the full mechanics of the setup, I'm not as confident that it is the only solution as I would be otherwise.

I think that Happeh has been more or less towntelling since her role was revealed, but there are a couple potential cracks in the façade. The most notable one to me was her ignoring denial's hard tunnel on her and explaining it away for a long time until she suddenly flipped and decided to fos him at the last second. I was struggling with understanding denial's hard tunnel for most of the day today, so I certainly would not have accepted it as easily as Happeh did if I was town.

I'm going to vote Happeh.

vote Happeh
TownOfSalemRox
over 6 years
I would like a clarification Birbtales.

Is it the first mafia that leads the vote the one who will kill?

If this is true, then we can assume either Happeh is the weakest of the mafia (hoh boy) or denial lied about rbing.

I was thinking we could lynch Happeh/denial, and if one is maf we lynch the other, effectively trading 1 ml for 1 ml.

Also, if Pinks is town then pinks is probably going to die before I did. Unless pinks already outted who she tracked.
iChaotic
over 6 years
Btw the mod indirectly confirmed that Happeh was town when he said the kill would Still go through. That means denials roleblock on happeh did not change anything that occured during the night or he would have initially said what he just told us now.