Ghost13 says

Birbtales says

There can be 2 Millers, 2 cops, 2 docs but no people have like the same exact card and roles

shady says

c'mon lad use your brain

shady can you explain i legit don't get it...

would Birbtales give us information about how many or which roles there are in the game? no. clearly hypothetical.

Carmen if the future ur vote needs to be bolded and have the word vote to count

iChaotic says

If he claims something good we would need to quickly flip to arogate.

Excuse me, why does Htennis's claim trump mine? You'd be fine with just blindly lynching me? but not htennis?

He's had enough time to do something, hasn't done anything, TOSR kinda freaked out, but I think I'm gonna back off of him for now, I'm getting town vibes off that, and I don't want a nl here, I'll go with htennis as my vote for today, if day is still going I'll be back later to reevaluate

Vote Htennis.

vote htennis

Whoever doesn't fu.cking tries to nl which is super unoptimal I will fu.cking policy lycnh them before my scum reads just because they are a determent to town if they are town. It's bull stop trying to nl idiots

If he claims something good we would need to quickly flip to arogate.

Ghost13 says

htennis says

I AM SOMETHING. THIS IS A PASSIONATE PLEA NOT TO LYNCH ME.

htennis says

I think shady is very sus and would be down for a lynch. If he's bomb it's no harm.

aiiight these are both AWFUL lines but what i don't understand is why would mafia care so little about this and say dumb stuff like this...

im reading this as overly confident pr who knows that he won't get lynched once he claims, but yes i definitely agree his lines are absolute sh*t :)

you and denial have similar reads there, but I just don't understand it. He is the only one actively being scummy. So we should vote him. If he is "overly confident pr who knows that he won't get lynched once he claims" then I guess we should put that theory to the test. It's honestly sus that you guys townread him despite these lines because it feels like you have inside info.

NL is probably more optimal than blindly lynching for the sake of lynching. it's not a waste of a lynch if htennis could provide us with a report tomorrow...

I dont care what his fu.cking role is we cannot risk a nl today it will waste one of our lynches.

nooo get him to claim FIRST we have only a few hours left and we are NOT lynching someone without them claiming

honestly im down to lynch htennis since i have no read on him VOTE HTENNIS

edit: everyone pile ur votes o htennis

ahhhh ok can we decide on a lynch tho it's better to use our lynch here right

the people i would scumread at the moment are:
denial (yup, i still dont like his responses and cant believe people are townreading him so easily)
TownOfSalemRox
mayhaps shady, i feel some of his posts are just for posting sake
LesbianPirate

i still TR goodfrog but he hasn't really been that active since i last checked. i also think carmen might be town too, she's made some good posts

everyone else is ehhh

so ive been busy and just got home from work. p tired & ive had a quick read and see people leaning on voting me - why me?!?! lel

i dislike posts that have suggested afk people are likely to be mafia when it's usually the opposite. townreading people based on making big explanative posts so early on is a huge warning sign of *MAFIA**MAFIA**MAFIA**

htennis says

I AM SOMETHING. THIS IS A PASSIONATE PLEA NOT TO LYNCH ME.

htennis says

I think shady is very sus and would be down for a lynch. If he's bomb it's no harm.

aiiight these are both AWFUL lines but what i don't understand is why would mafia care so little about this and say dumb stuff like this...

im reading this as overly confident pr who knows that he won't get lynched once he claims, but yes i definitely agree his lines are horrible :)

Birbtales says

There can be 2 Millers, 2 cops, 2 docs but no people have like the same exact card and roles

shady says

c'mon lad use your brain

shady can you explain i legit don't get it...

Carmen you need to make your htennis vote bold for it to count.

OK, here are my notes.

htennis is scum. The reasons are thus: he has no town lines. he has scum lines. And you would think if he were town that mafia would see him as an easy opportunity to push a lynch on. But the only two people fosing him are me and (literally as I come to type this: Carmen). Which brings me to my second read:

Carmen is town. I am not going to go into any further detail other than I just feel like she is town based on her personality and play in this game. You don't have to take my read into account, develop your own, but I feel strongly that she is town.

I do not townread denial. I said he was towny earlier but on further review, he has pretty much only said mechanical based comments, and the reads he outed, to me either don't have substance or are jarring with the way I read the game myself. I'm not saying he is mafia, I just haven't seen a comparable town mindset from him yet this game.

I don't understand all the foses on Arrogate. He has come across as pretty towny to me. So does TownOfSalemRox.

I am pretty sure LesbianPirate is town. I also think iChaotic is town. They both had a couple lines I really liked.

Earlier I hard tr goodfrog, during this reread he didn't stand out to me one way or the other.

I don't think Elfen has been towny at all. I don't think mw295 has been very towny.

I get mixed signals from Ghost13, she had a couple lines that I thought were hunting PRs as mafia, and a couple of lines that I thought came from a town mindset.

EDIT:

I left out Happeh. I thought her initial push on denial was weird but it also seemed like she softed PR; I'm not sure if I scumread her as much as earlier.

I nominate we lynch htennis, who I am already voting.

if we lynch happen instead of htennis I'm going to game related sui

ok honestly I'm gonna do a little personal exercise and go through everyone's posts and give my feedback since I don't really feel comfortable on any of my reads at this point.

iChaotic says

LesbianPirate: stop asking people to claim if u keep doing these u will be policed in later days. Asking people to claim unnecessarily is super scummy

I'VE ONLY ASKED ONE PERSON TO CLAIM?! WHY ARE YOU REACHING SIS?!

and it wasn't unnecessary people were fosing denial so

Ghost13 says

Birb is there for sure 2 millers, 2 cops, 2 docs or UP TO 2 millers, 2 cops, 2 docs?

c'mon lad use your brain