Miller and Godfather should still appear as village-sided and mafia-sided respectively.

The thing is, he wouldn't know WHAT alignment they were, just that they were on different sides.
And yes, mafia pretty much always have to cc prs.

Xavier, I can see it, too, I'm imagining situations where the Mad Scientist is the clear in a 5-Way-LYLO, and he got two targets that didn't die. Overall, I can safely say that the Mad Scientist will need to be CC'd in most setups.

Only time it wouldn't work is with 1 mafia.

Investigate 2 people, they both show up as sided with the village, lynch the one that's not clear, gg.

Godfather and miller would who up village and mafia respectively right? If so I like it. It would make for a good lead role in scum hunting games, where all you have is that one is scum and one isnt.

I'm not sure. It's interesting at the beginning but with a mislynch it's too dangerous. It gives too many clears too quickly, or too many mafia too quickly. That's just my opinion.

Hmm, I like it a lot, actually. But it may be a little OP at the later stages of the game.

Interviewer? Journalist?

Good job, Prime

How about "Marriage Counselor"

I also like this. But I do see a need for a name change. Maybe something as simple as Interrogator, or if he isn't personally checking them maybe even just Scientist?

Eh, it seems fitting given the nature of the checks. What names can you guys think of?

Nice role, needs a new name though.

This is a good idea, but I don't know if "Mad Scientist" is the right name.

I like it . :)

@renai: much much more powerful. It's hard for me to explain, but try to work the math out.

Cool investigative role, I would enjoy this. How much stronger would it be if it could re-use players in checks?

Some roles from witchhunt are definitely roles I'd like to see here, but not all of them would work here.
I also have a few of my own that I'm still thinking about.

Are you going to suggest all of the witchhunt roles?Cause if so silencer would be pretty easy to make and fun to do.
Spy would be very op or very UP though.

I like this a lot. Gives useful information to town without being so detailed as to be OP. +1