mw, I'm seriously on the same level as Chaotic in your books?
again, you'd super buddy a maf partner TO say "why would I do that"
I mean, yeah you have to start somewhere, thus my great push on TOSR, I definitely got reads from it I have no clue why I ultimatly voted htennis, like I dont remember, but hey it turned out to be ok cause nothing happened
@Arrogate (I couldn't quote cause message too long)
1) The difference between Carmen and Denial is enormous. One is a known troll, the other is one of the most serious ppl here. Denial is also clearly trying to push town forward, and I haven't seen Carmen do that. 2) Again, why tf would 2 mafias buddy each other in a game where it's 10 town 3 mafia lol 3) I literally wrote out this whole thing explaining the numbers and then realized you're 100% right cause of the double vote power. That would make the role incredibly mafia sided. I retract my fos on happeh.
My TRs were all explained in an earlier post. Make it 7 now that you and Happeh has been added lol
So in summary, this is where I'm at rn:
Def town: LP/Denial Almost def town: Shady/Happeh Likely town: Arrogate/iChaotic/TOSR
Got me feelin' some kinda way (prob not good tho): Ghost/Tennis/Frog/Carmen/Elfen
Ik it's a lot, but you have to start somewhere and build on reads. I don't think that playing this game via POE is a bad thing, especially when we don't know the different possible roles ahead of time. As I said before, I'm treating this mostly as a scumhunt :)
Referencing the log, iChaotic never had a chance to hammer anyone. But is his desire to just get a lynch through scummy? I say no, because lynching with 13 is optimal. Secondly, that fos would only make sense if htennis and happeh were both town.
I mean, do these lines say anything to yall? or are yall over looking them? this is literally not towny, I get the wanting to lynch, but like he was even flipping around so that shows he had no reason for a lynch on either, just a lynch to lynch one
I'm seeing that Carmen is much more participating today that yesterday. This could be good, but could also be bad. Also how can I like what htennis just said, of having "liabilities" like happeh? I think that htennis and happeh are both mafia and they are just trying to lead the lynch someone outside them.
I'd really rather not - but I will say that there's no reason for 2/3 mafias to buddy each other, especially this early on. Hopefully you can trust that.
1. Carmen was also using a bunch of outside information, where's your tr on her? 2. That's kinda sketch to say, "very clearly my partner" that'd be a new way to defend a maf partner tbh 3. So if maf actually has this vig role, town literally only has 1 ml? and with 1 ml that makes this impossible tbh
I find it really hard to believe that you have 5 trs already tbh
deletedover 6 years
@mw could you explain why she's clear town to you*
1) As Shady pointed out (which makes me feel validated lmao), Denial is using past/outside information to try to push town forward. I TR'd Denial D1 because he's taking a lot of attention on himself and trying to actually create reads/gather information, which mafia has no reason to do. 2) Just leave LP alone thx. She's just very clear town to me. 3) I think that in a game where mafia has a 10-3 disadvantage, giving them a one shot extra kill helps even things out, and double votes would be a way to secretly influence a lynch (although to hide it you'd need to be v careful about who you voted and when). I think it'd be an awesome maf role lol and would make yesterday make a lot more sense.
I also forgot to mention, I think TOSR is pretty towny as well.
deletedover 6 years
i finished late and transport is meh so i doubt i'll have any time when i get home to write something extensive. i'm on an early tomorrow so after this post i wont be on till around 5-6pm bst rip
i do not understand any TRs on Carmen. her disregard for rules seems more like mafia than town.
i can understand a TR of LP as her posts can be taken multiple ways - i.e. she often jokes about vote/SR her. i don't necessarily think she's town atm though
i have a scumread that i'm going to keep hidden and shoot tonight.
The 50 pages thing was only meant to spur more discussion, I think if I see (as I have somewhat today) an uptake in the amount of quality posts and discussion it will be removed
@Forg not yet, that was up next lol. I've been threatened to catch up and post while at work which is tough (I guess I'm the only one who works 12-14 hour days lmao) but that's how I'm prob gonna determine which is the better lynch. Although based on the voting either one of them at least is maf or maf is stupid and allowed the nl to happen during a TvT
