i've read all three! i liked both the hunger games and catching fire (out of the trilogy, this is probably my favorite) but mockingjay was really sloppy and disappointing to me so i like to pretend it doesn't exist.
I'm not sure you would have though; even with Michael's bias, he was confused. But to me the solid evidence is that he asked me, as vig, to kill someone, and I did. End of story. I proved that. It would have been sheer luck if that happened to just be the "real" vig's kill or something. I don't know. You sure fought hard for an unranked though!